Public executions used to be a spectator sport. Even today we
are all fascinated by a good disaster – as long as it’s happening to something
else. Disaster and scandal sell
magazines and newspapers and keep news shows in business.
This human tendency to be interested in bad news was as
prevalent in Jesus’ day as it is now. In today’s gospel reading, Jesus is
asked, “Did you hear about the Galileans whose blood Pilate mingled with their
sacrifices?” Presumably these people were killed while they were at the temple
offering sacrifice. Jesus uses this as a teaching moment. “Do you think that because these Galileans suffered in this way they
were worse sinners than all other Galileans?” In other words, “do you think
that somehow you are better than these people that you glory in their
misfortune?” And then he relates it to accidental death – “do you think that
the people killed by a falling tower were somehow more sinful then everyone
else living in Jerusalem?”
I don’t think that Jesus is
talking about why bad things happen to good people, but about the foolish idea
that we are superior to others. “Unless you repent,” he says, “you will all
perish just as they did."
When things go badly wrong we want
to make sense of it. We look for someone or something to blame. “She got cancer
because of her diet- if only she hadn’t eaten all that meat” or “I got cancer
because of the stress caused by my last parish.” Those are both statements I
have heard in the last few months. There may indeed be causes we can point to –
the Galileans may have been insurgents, the tower may have been badly
engineered – but our desire is to blame. When we have someone to blame we can
feel better and safer. This is part of the underlying mechanism of
Often we blame God. We think we
must be being punished. There is a strand of Biblical teaching which suggests
that God disciplines us, and we equate this with being punished for having been
bad. Many of us, however sophisticated, still have a big angry God in our heads
who pops out when things go wrong and wags his finger at us. “Did you really
think I loved you after all you’ve done?”
This is one of the reasons that
people lose their faith. They think that if God loves them there will be no
personal disasters. All disasters will happen to other people. Then something
terrible happens – a child is killed, a job is lost amid false accusations –
and the big angry God wags his finger at them. They feel that God has failed to
keep his side of the bargain. Surely the deal was that if we are good nothing
bad will happen, right?
When 9/11 happened there were many
people who were not in the Twin Towers at the time who should have been. Were
they somehow better than all those who died?
Jesus says, “No, I tell you; but
unless you repent, you will all perish just as they did." Clearly we are
all going to die, so what can he mean by this? If we repent will we be saved
from disaster? No, it just doesn’t work that way. God’s love is just as great
for those stabbed in Anaheim yesterday, for the family murdered by their father
in India this morning, and for those killed by Russian and Syrian bombing
today, as for those of us sitting here in these pews.
We are all the same. We are all
connected. In that mysterious web of life, their disaster IS our disaster.
Luke has given us a second
teaching of Jesus’ in this section of his gospel. They are in some way
connected in Luke’s mind because he does not start a new section as he
typically does with “at that time” or “on the Sabbath” or with a short
description of where Jesus was and who was with him. Here he just continues
straight on, “Then he told this parable…” So there is a relationship. What
light can the parable of the fig tree throw on all this?
When the big angry God is at the
forefront of our minds we will think that the owner who wants to cut down the
tree is God. The God who thinks we’ve really had enough time to shape up and we’ve
finally blown it. But what if this is just a teaching story about farming? What
if we aren’t meant to think that anyone is God?
Perhaps the reason Jesus told this
story is to show that even a farmer will give a tree another chance and will
give it more fertilizer; try to help it be the best fig tree it can be. If
that’s what farmers do, can’t we believe that God will do even better for us?
Instead of cutting us down because
we’re not bearing enough fruit, God will give us more fertilizer. God does not
punish people by having towers fall on them, or letting them experience pain.
God’s love for us is so great that every time we turn towards God, every little
step of repentance that we take is met by a bigger divine movement towards us.
Christ’s saving work in his life,
death and resurrection is available for all who turn towards God. Yes we will
all die - hopefully peacefully in our beds but maybe in accident or disaster.
But those of us who are enrolled in the reign of God know that this is not the
only reality. We are the ones who are living the future as if it is already
here. We are the ones who know that God’s mercy is abundant and God’s love is
everlasting. We may die, yet we will not perish in fear and terror but in the
quiet confidence that we can rest in God’s arms.
This is one of the meanings of
Christ’s death and resurrection. He showed that God is powerful even over
death. Whether we perseverate over it or deny it, death is an ever present
reality in our lives and in our culture. But it is not a big deal in God’s
culture. Yes, Jesus died a horrible death. But he came back to life. Just like
childbirth can be terribly painful yet women forget the pain in the joy of the
new life; so the pain of a difficult death is forgotten and obliterated by the
joy of the resurrection.
We can perish without hope or we
can die knowing that God is holding us, because during our lifetimes we have
sought out God. We have longed for God, and God has responded to us. Not
perhaps in the way we expect. Not perhaps keeping us free from personal
disaster and pain, but God has turned to us as we have turned to God.
John Bradford, a 16th
century Anglican who was a renowned preacher and eventually a martyr is reputed to have said whenever he saw people
being led to execution, “There but for the grace of God goes John Bradford.”
When we hear accounts of disaster,
let us respond with compassion, and the love that God nurtures in our hearts. It
is through the grace of God that we take very breath. It is through the grace
of God that we live in peace and plenty. It is through the grace of God that we
know that dying is not the end, and that God’s love and life conquer every
expression of death.